I’m striving to be more consistent with my postings. It has been a hectic week, though, trying to finish up all of my projects for classes. I’m finished with all but one. Praise God. Interestingly enough, one of my papers dealt with a topic that I’ve really struggled with over the last couple of years: the tension between contemporary church and traditional church. This is a very deep and divisive issue in Evangelical America. I’m a young guy, often playing contemporary styles of music, so of course I tend to partner myself with “contemporary” congregations. At the same time, I realize that there is a need for scriptural centrality in our corporate worship services. This is an area that a lot of models for contemporary structures fall short. We get so busy trying to be “culturally relevant” that we forget the bible in it’s infinite and eternal relevance. As a pastor once said, “Give it to me plain, let the spirit do the rest.”
So, as I was doing my paper, I was trying to decipher the core model for corporate worship in the New Testament. We have a few ordinances (baptism and communion), but otherwise, structure is up for grabs. I thought about how Jesus changed everything, though. He talked about how this New Covenant, his total fulfillment of the law… well… it just wouldn’t fit into the old ways of doing things (Luke 5.33-39). Religiousness was going to be traded in. Faithful and dutiful worship would not be, though, and thats where things get tricky.
The appealing thing about religion is that you know precisely what actions you have to do to please your god. But relationship is different. It’s fueled by an inner desire that causes you to do things that please the other person. Think about how you interact with family. This is all the more difficult, because with God, you only see a part of Him. Only what he has revealed through His Son; like looking in a mirror dimly (1 Cor. 13.12). So religion is easy. And we are lazy. And that’s precisely the reason for Luke 5.39!
Anyhow, I think “contemporary” versus “traditional” is really relationship versus religion. What is talked about in the New Testament as necessary is biblical Truth, love and fellowship. These are the core needs of the church. However you decide to get there is up to the congregation. People who wear flip flops to church are just as likely to value the aesthetics of a worship service as the people who dress in suits and ties. If your structure is as important as (or sometimes MORE important than) faithful worship, then you have a problem.
Contemporary church means genuinely meeting the needs of a body, without looking to the way things have been done before, assuming that there is some extra means of grace in it. Format is not part of the equation. Sing your hymns. Sing your pop hits. As long as it’s done in the Spirit of worship, it’s glorifying to God.
My paper is actually a bit more eloquent, and far more informative than this blog. If you want to read it, comment or email me. It’s only a few pages long, but it’s way better than this rant.